FREE SHIPPING & 14 DAY RETURNS
  • Shop All
  • New Arrivals
  • Engagement
  • Bands
  • Cocktail
  • Custom
  • Book an Appointment
  • Contact
  • About
  • Standards
  • All Rings
  • New Arrivals
  • Engagement Rings
    • Vintage Engagement Rings
    • Erstwhile Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
    • Vintage Bands
    • Erstwhile Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Cocktail Rings
  • Custom Engagement Rings
  • Contact Us
  • Book An Appointment
  • Return Policy
  • About Us
  • Account
  • Wishlist
Collection
  • View All
  • Vintage Engagement Rings
  • Erstwhile Engagement Rings
  • Classic Solitaire Collection
  • Vintage Tiffany & Co.
  • Custom & Stone Reset
  • Sold
Era
  • Victorian
  • Edwardian
  • Art Deco
  • Mid Century
Setting
  • Solitare
  • Three Stone
  • Cluster
  • Halo
  • Bezel
  • Navette
Cut
  • Old European Cut
  • Old Mine Cushion Cut
  • Emerald Cut
  • Asscher Cut
  • Marquise Cut
  • Rose Cut
Metal
  • Platinum
  • Yellow Gold
  • Rose Gold
  • Two Tone
Erstwhile Engagement Rings
Vintage Engagement Rings
Collection
  • Vintage Bands
  • Erstwhile Bands
  • Bands for Him
Metal
  • Platinum Bands
  • Blackened Metal Bands
  • Gold Bands
  • Rose Gold Bands
Style
  • Eternity Bands
  • Diamond Bands
  • Plain Bands
  • Sapphire Bands
Erstwhile Bands
Bands For Him
About
  • Custom Design Process
  • Custom Engagement Ring Gallery
  • Customizable Settings
Our Most Popular Rings on Pinterest - Erstwhile Jewelry

Our Most Popular Rings on Pinterest

Timeless Elegance: Mixing Vintage & Erstwhile Rings with Style Influencer Taylr Anne - Erstwhile Jewelry

Timeless Elegance: Mixing Vintage & Erstwhile Rings with Style Influencer Taylr Anne

A Conversation with Haley Boyd - Erstwhile Jewelry

A Conversation with Haley Boyd

History of Gold in Jewelry - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

History of Gold in Jewelry

Antique Tiaras From Cartier - Erstwhile Jewelry

Antique Tiaras From Cartier

Decoding the Sparkle: Antique Old European Cut vs. Modern Round Brilliant Cut Diamonds - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

Decoding the Sparkle: Antique Old European Cut vs. Modern Round Brilliant Cut Diamonds

Brilliance & Fire - Erstwhile Jewelry

Brilliance & Fire

History of Engagement Rings - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

History of Engagement Rings

Are Old European Cuts as Valuable as Diamonds of Today? - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

Are Old European Cuts as Valuable as Diamonds of Today?

How to Figure Out Your Engagement Ring Budget? - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

How to Figure Out Your Engagement Ring Budget?

History of Diamond Cutting - Erstwhile Jewelry
education

History of Diamond Cutting

Top 6 Vintage Engagement Rings of 2015 - Erstwhile Jewelry
the jewelry edit

Top 6 Vintage Engagement Rings of 2015

  • 1
  • 2
Your Cart
Your cart is currently empty.
Continue Shopping
Discover Products
Erstwhile Collection
Vintage Collection

Since 2010, Erstwhile has been a coveted NYC destination for antique and vintage engagement rings. Guided by an appreciation for all things bygone and a commitment to quality, Erstwhile also curates collectible vintage rings, wedding bands and namesake handcrafted pieces set with antique diamonds.

CONTACT US

589 Fifth Ave, New York NY 10017

212-390-1144

info@erstwhilejewelry.com

OPENING TIMES

Monday — Friday (Closed Saturday & Sunday)

10am — 6pm EST

Book an Appointment

JOIN THE HUNT

Subscribe to our newsletter and get first access to new arrivals and sales.

Customer Care
  • Ring Sizing
  • Warranty & Repairs
  • Return Policy
  • Payment Options & Financing
  • Shipping
  • FAQ's
About Us
  • Our Story
  • Our Standards
  • Journal
  • Reviews
  • Stockists
Services
  • Custom
  • Set Your Stone
  • Concierge Service
  • Gem Certification
©2025 Erstwhile Jewelry, all rights reserved
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Tiktok
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility